difference between sag mill and ball mill

Ball, Pebble and SAG Mills: A Buyers Guide

Image credit. All three (the Ball, Pebble and SAG) are operational within the same type of housing, however each type of mill has a different practicality and purpose. Understanding which mill is better for different tasks will …

SAG Mill Grinding Circuit Design

SAG Mill vs Ball Mill. Ball Motion inside a SAG Mill. Ball Motion inside a Ball Mill. To a more significant degree than in other comminution devices, liner design and configuration can have a …

Differences in Properties between Pebbles and Raw Ore from a SAG Mill

Semi-autogenous (SAG) mills are widely used grinding equipment, but some ore with critical particle sizes cannot be effectively processed by SAG mills and turned into pebbles. This research aims to analyze and compare the properties of raw ore and pebbles from a zinc- and tin-bearing ore. The results show that the contents of sphalerite, …

Ball Mill vs Rod Mill: Which is the Best for Your Mining …

One of the advantages of a rod mill is that it can handle a higher capacity than a ball mill of the same size. Additionally, the grinding medium in a rod mill is more uniform than that in a ball mill, and this can be beneficial for certain materials. Rod mills are also relatively low-maintenance, making them a cost-effective option for many ...

SAG Mill Grinding Circuit Design

SAG Mill vs Ball Mill. Ball Motion inside a SAG Mill. Ball Motion inside a Ball Mill. To a more significant degree than in other comminution devices, liner design and configuration can have a substantial effect on mill performance. In general terms, lifter spacing and angle, grate open area and aperture size, and pulp lifter design and capacity …

Ball Charge and Grinding Efficiency

Ball feed size SAG mill water flow rate SAG mill power vs. wear geometry - maximizing kW-hr/ton & tons/hour in combination SAG mill liner change-out life/cycle vs. tons/kg consumed. Ball mill liner efficiency based on liner geometry and its influence on kW-hours/ton, total tons/life cycle, and P80 transfer to cyclones. Ball mill grind is based ...

SAG Mill Testing

SAG MILL TESTING - AN OVERVIEW OF THE TEST PROCEDURES AVAILABLE TO CHARACTERIZE ORE ... Bond Ball Mill 0.305 3.35 Any 0.149 10 5 Locked-cycle Y Y Mod Bond 0.305 3.35 Any N/A 2 1.2 Batch N Y ... to observe a difference (sometimes significant) between the rod mill and ball mill index values for a given ore type (McKen, …

What's the difference of Ball mill, SAG mill, AG …

Watch on. SAG mill vs Ball mill. 1.Appearance. Both sag mill and ball mil are cyclinder type grinding mill. SAG mills usually have a larger diameter than length. While ball mills have a larger length than …

What is the Difference Between SAG and AG Mill?

The length of the cylindrical shell is usually 1.5 to 2.5 times the diameter of the shell. The SAG mill operates in a closed circuit with a screen. The product from the SAG mill is fed to a ball mill, which operates in a closed circuit with a cyclone. The SAG mill and ball mill are both cylindrical in shape and have a small horizontal axis.

Choosing a SAG Mill To Achieve Design Performance

Choosing a SAG Mill To Achieve Design Performance. John Starkey1, Principal Consulting Engineer Sami Hindstrom2, Manager, Grinding Travis Orser2, Project Manager, Grinding. Starkey & Associates Grinding Design and Process Engineering 336 – 268 Lakeshore Rd. E. Oakville, Ontario L6J 7S4 PH: (905) 465-7512 Fax (905) 844-5297.

Roller Mills vs Hammer Mills

A roller mill can efficiently break down grain for livestock feed. Energy efficiency is especially pronounced in electric grain roller mills. In some situations, roller mills use 85% less energy to process grain than hammer mills. In the most common processing situations, though, the energy savings are likely 30-50%.

What's the Difference Between Ball Mill, Rod Mill and SAG Mill?

Ball mill: When the particle size of the product is less than 0.5mm, the grinding effect of the ball mill is greater than that of a rod mill of the same specification. …

AG Mill and SAG Mill

AG Mill and SAG Mill. Feeding size: ≤25mm. Capacity: 0.65-615t/h. Output size: 0.074-0.89mm. Applications: It is commonly used in the mineral processing industry and ferrous and non-ferrous metal ore and nonmetal …

SAG vs Ball Mills

It's important to point out that in a SAG mill, the crushing load is composed of two components; the mineral rocks and the iron balls. Thus the mineral type affects SAG mills more than ball mills. Due to the heterogeneous nature of the foundations, the minerals don't possess a single hardness. The existence of this variance is what causes ...

How HPGRs compare to conventional milling | Weir

Ball, SAG and rod mills all require their grinding media to be regularly replaced, unlike a HPGR. High Pressure Grinding Rolls have lower maintenance overheads than ball and rod mills, primarily because the grinding media in conventional mills needs to be replaced on a more regular basis. This makes HPGRs more flexible when it comes to meeting ...

How it Works: Crushers, Grinding Mills and Pulverizers

Rod mills are similar to ball mills and use metal rods as the grinding media. Pebble mills use rock pebbles as the grinding media to cause friction and attrition between the pebbles and ore material. Pebble mills may be used when metal balls must be avoided. Autogenous grinding (AG) and semi-autogenous grinding (SAG) mills use the material …

SAG Mill | Autogenous and Semi-Autogenous Mills

Single stage SAG Mills are very beneficial in reducing CAPEX for plants with a staged throughput approach. When future tonnage is to be increased, the SAG Mill can feed downstream ball milling to boost capacity. Fuller-Traylor SAG/AG Mills range in size from 4.3m through 12.2m in diameter with powers as high as 28,000 kW.

Autogenous Grinding & Semi Autogenous …

Semi-autogenous plus ball mill has been the "work horse" of mills. SAG vs Ball Mill Advantages . AG & SAG Mill Grinding Compared – Which is Best. ... A single or two stage grinding and concentration mill. . …

What Is The Difference Between A Ball Mill And A Sag Mill?

In a SAG mill, balls of up to 150mm in diameter occupy 5%-18% of the mill chamber volume. In contrast, a ball mill contains grinding media up to 50mm in diameter, …

Overflow VS Grate Discharge Ball or Mill

The cost of a ball mill conversion from overflow to grate discharge is 'fairly' affordable at $65,000 for a 13′ x 15′ mill. This is only for the discharge head, grates and pulp filters (rubber). A comparison in laboratory of Overflow Discharge Ball Mill VS Grate Discharge Ball Mill.

Comparative Analysis of Rod Mill and Ball Mill

The reason why rod mill is called rod mill is that its grinding medium is steel rod, while the grinding medium of ball grinding mill is steel ball. Because the shape of the grinding media is different, the working mode has its own characteristics. When the steel rod is in motion, the gap between the rods is a regular long strip, which plays a ...

What is a Semi-Autogenous Mill?

What is the difference between a SAG mill and a ball mill? A SAG mill uses larger rocks or ore fragments as grinding media, while a ball mill uses smaller grinding media such as steel balls. Additionally, a SAG mill uses a minimal ball charge of 6 to 15%, while a ball mill requires a higher ball charge of 20 to 40%.

Keys to best practice comminution

In all cases, understanding of the transfer size (T 80) between the SAG mill and the ball mill is critical to achieve best economics in a semi-autogenous mill (SAG) grinding plant. T 80 is important to operators because when the SAG energy and the Bond Ball Mill Work Index on SAG ground ore are measured, accurate prediction of future …

RoM BALL MILLS

SAG mills SAG mills are normally operated with ball loads ranges from 5 – 18 % volumetric filling while RoM ball mills are operated with ball loads ranging between 25 and 40% volumetric filling.

Difference Between Sag Mill vs Ball Mill

Ball mill is a fine grinder. A horizontal or vertical rotating cylinder which is filled partially with the balls of ceramics, small rocks and balls made from stainless steel. The ball charge of a SAG mill is about 29% to 30%. By …

Ball Mill VS AG Mill: What are the Similarities and Differences?

1. Structure. Although the overall structure of autogenous grinding mill and ball mill are similar, but there are differences in details. There are differences in the ratio of the length and width of the barrel between ball mill and AG mill. The large diameter and short length of the barrel of the AG mill reduce the axial segregation of ...

Autogenous and Semi-Autogenous Mills

ρ b = ball density (t/m 3) 9.4. AG/SAG Mill Power. In designing crushing–grinding flow sheets, correct estimations of mill power draw are important as it serves as one of the deciding factors for selecting an option between AG/SAG mills. In most cases, the circuit with the least or optimal power consumption is the preferred choice.

Ball Mill (Ball Mills Explained)

Crushed ore is fed to the ball mill through the inlet; a scoop (small screw conveyor) ensures the feed is constant. For both wet and dry ball mills, the ball mill is charged to approximately 33% with balls (range 30-45%). Pulp (crushed ore and water) fills another 15% of the drum's volume so that the total volume of the drum is 50% charged.

RoM Ball mills

References (15) ... In comparison to conventional tumbling mills, i.e., rod-and ball mills, the grinding media in an AG mill derive from the feed ore itself (Gupta and Yan, 2016;Hahne et al., 2003 ...

A Comprehensive Guide to SAG Mill Operation

SAG mills operate differently from ball mills, which rely on the impact of balls to break down the material. SAG mills use a combination of impact and attrition to grind the …